Appropriation Image Analysis: Peer Review
Name: ___________________ Teacher:
Date : ___________________ Title of Work: ___________________
 
Criteria
Points
1
2
3
4
 
Demonstrate understanding about the context, purpose and audience of the original image.
Identifies the original image's creator.
Identifies the original image's creator and partially describes the social context in which it was created and/or the purpose and audience for whom the image was created.
Identifies the original image's creator and explains the social context in which it was created as well as a detailed description of the purpose and audience for whom the image was created.
Identifies the original image's creator and explains, in a detailed and sophisticated manner, the social context in which the image was created as well as the purpose and audience for whom the image was created.
____
Makes comparisons between the original and appropriated images.
Makes some observations about the two images.
Identifies one or two similarities and differences between the two images
identifies and explains the similarities and differences between the two images and refers to the techniques used to achieve this.
Identifies and clearly explains the similarities and differences between the two images as well as giving a thorough analysis of the techniques used to achieve the transformation.
____
Identifies the context and purpose of the new image and the audience for whom it has been created.
Identifies either the context, purpose or audience of the new image, but not all 3.
Identifies 2 of a combination of context, purpose and audience.
Clearly Identifies and explains the context and purpose of the new image as well as a discussion about the audience at which it is directed.
Clearly Identifies and explains in a sophisticated manner the context and purpose of the new image as well as an enlightened discussion about the target audience.
____
Decodes the Meaning
Does not attempt to analyze the image and decode its meaning.
Attempts to discuss the image's new meaning.
Analyses the image and explains what the new meaning of the image is with reference to the techniques used to achieve this.
Provides a sophisticated analysis of the techniques used to manipulate the image and a detailed discussion about how they have made new meaning. Techniques discussed will refer to form, medium, genre and language. features.
____
Evaluates the appropriated image
Gives a vague opinion about whether the image is successful or not.
States in brief and attempts to give evidence of why the image is successful or not.
Provides a well constructed statement about why the image is successful or not making reference to at least one aspect or technique as evidence.
Provides a sophisticated analysis and opinion about why the image is successful or not drawing extensively on aspects or techniques as examples of evidence.
____
       
Total---->
____

Teacher Comments:

 


This rubric is from www.TeacherJet.com