Evaluating Young Adult Literature
Name: ___________________ Teacher:
Date : ___________________ Title of Work: ___________________
 
Criteria
Points
1
2
3
4
 
Characterization
Characters are portrayed as caricatures of the culture being presented. Characters are described with several stereotypes and/or biases.
Characters are somewhat believable but are questionable. Characters are described with a few stereotypes and/or biases.
Characters are believable, grow naturally, and show depth. Characters are described with stereotypes and biases.
Characters are believable, grow naturally, and show depth. Characters are described without exaggeration in relation to their culture.
____
Setting
Setting is unnatural in relation to the content. Setting is typical to the culture presented.
Setting is in keeping with the content of the book. Setting could be typical to the culture presented.
Setting is natural in relation to the content of the book. Setting is described using stereotypes.
Setting is natural in relation to the content of the book and is described without using stereotypes. Setting is universal instead of typical to the culture.
____
Audience and Purpose
The target audience is above or below young adult ability or interest level. The purpose of the book does not deal with contemporary issues, problems, or experiences.
The target audience is young adults. The purpose of the book does not deal with contemporary issues, problems, or experiences.
The audience targeted is young adults. The purpose of the book deals with contemporary issues, problems, and experiences with characters to whom adolescents can relate.
The audience targeted is young adults. The purpose of the book deals with contemporary issues, problems, and experiences with characters to whom adolescents can relate. The book: -provides pleasure reading -may teach adolescents about diverse peoples and the world beyond their community -may demonstrate a range of human emotions and allow adolescents to experience them as a result of reading quality literature -may reveal realities of life -may provide vicarious experiences -may allow readers to escape into the realms of fantasy -introduces readers to excellent writers and writing
____
Interest and Reading Level
The Reading Level is too easy or too difficult for young adults. The content of the book does not match young adult interest levels.
The Reading Level is too easy or too difficult for young adults. The content of the book matches young adult interest levels by dealing with contemporary issues, problems, and experiences with characters to whom adolescents can relate.
The Reading Level matches that of young adults. The interest level of the book matches young adult interest levels by dealing with contemporary issues, problems, and experiences with characters to whom adolescents can relate.
The Reading Level (RL) and Interest Level (IL) matches that of young adults by dealing with contemporary issues, problems, and experiences with characters to whom adolescents can relate(levels can be found on front, back, or inside cover of book).
____
____
       
Total---->
____

Teacher Comments:

 


This rubric is from www.TeacherJet.com