|
|
1
|
2
|
3
|
4
|
|
|
Speech Format
|
No paragraphs, small amount of writing, No clear beginning or ending
|
Slight indication of beginning or ending, small amount of writing, one or two paragraphs
|
Transitional ideas, average amount of writing, a few paragraphs discussing different topics
|
Transitional ideas, great amount of writing, diverse paragraphs in the correct order indicating a clear beginning and ending
|
____
|
|
Persuasive Language
|
No language arguing a point and denying an opposing view point
|
Some language arguing a point and denying an opposing view point
|
Average amount of language arguing a point and denying an opposing view point
|
Controlled and powerful language arguing a point and denying an opposing view point
|
____
|
|
Grammar
|
No indication of correct punctuation or grammar for grade level
|
Small amount of correct usage of grammar and punctuation for grade level
|
Average amount of correct usage of grammar and punctuation for grade level
|
Above average grammar and punctuation, exceeding expectations for grade level
|
____
|
|
Novel Evidence
|
No reference to the novel or citing evidence and details to support argument
|
One reference to the novel or citing evidence and details to support argument
|
Two references to the novel or citing evidence and details to support argument
|
Three or more references to the novel or citing evidence and details to support argument
|
____
|
|
Stable Argument
|
Changing opinions between Roger and Jack's guilt, No clear position of argument
|
Few changes between Roger and Jack's guilt, slightly unclear position of argument
|
Only one mention of uncertainty between Roger and Jack's guilt, clear position of argument
|
Clear position of argument with organization and evidence to support
|
____
|
| |
|
|
|
Total---->
|
____
|